| Season 1 | ||
| Champion: Aaron W |
| Season 2 | ||
| Champion: Aaron W | Second Place: Erik G | Third Place: Matt L |
| Season 3 | ||
| Champion: Aaron W | Second Place: Matt L | Third Place: Carl A |
| Season 4 | ||
| Champion: Erik G | Second Place: John Q | Third Place: Aaron W |
| Season 5 | ||
| Co-Champion: Erik G | Co-Champion: Matt L | Third Place: Aaron W |
| Season 6 | ||
| Champion: Aaron W | Second Place: John Q | Third Place: Matt L |
| Season 7 | ||
| Champion: Erik G | Second Place: Aaron W | Third Place: Justin B |
| Season 8 | ||
| Champion: Erik G | Second Place: Scott C | Third Place: Justin B |
| Season 9 | ||
| Champion: | Second Place: | Third Place: |